The Dash Family’s Roles

By Mark Nichol

The en dash is the oft-neglected middle sibling of the horizontal-line family of symbols that serve to connect words and numbers for various reasons.

The em dash (—) is the dashing member of the brood, used somewhat sparingly to indicate a sudden break in syntax—either to signal a shift in sentence construction, as here, or joining with a twin to frame a parenthetical word or phrase (just as a pair of commas would be used in the midst of a sentence or two parentheses would be employed anywhere).

The smallest, the hyphen (-), is the busiest, indicating connections between words, such as when the phrase “highest scoring” is hyphenated to signal its combined modification of the word that follows in the phrase “highest-scoring player” or to link two numbers in reference to a score or vote.

The en dash (–), however, sometimes steps in to take the place of the hyphen: It is employed when an open compound is part of the phrasal adjective, signaling that the entire compound, not just the last word in the compound, is linked to the next word, as in “Civil War–era artifacts” (rather than “Civil War-era” or “Civil-War-era”) or “Los Angeles–to–San Francisco flight” (rather than in “Los Angeles-to-San Francisco flight” or “Los-Angeles-to-San-Francisco flight”).

Note, however, that open compounds need not be proper nouns, as this quip about an advertising agency with a name consisting of a sequence of initials demonstrates: “This alphabet soup–named firm helps get clients on the gravy train.” If a hyphen were used in place of an en dash here, the reference would (confusingly) be to a soup-named agency of an alphabet nature. (Also, some publishers, presumably for aesthetic reasons, employ en dashes in place of em dashes.)

The other major function of an en dash, by the way, is to replace to to indicate a number range, as in “Answer quiz questions 1–10.” (Remember that because scores are not number ranges, a hyphen is the correct symbol for linking two totals.) In both types of usage, a hyphen is often erroneously employed in place of an en dash (though for the sake of simplicity, some publications, especially newspapers, deliberately avoid use of the en dash).

Also, note that although both hyphens and en dashes are employed as minus signs, the minus sign is technically a distinct symbol that in formal publishing is set using a distinct code. In informal usage, an en dash, more equivalent in size to plus and equal signs than a hyphen, is preferable.

Recommended for you: « »
Improve your English: « Subscribe to our posts and exercises »



6 Responses to “The Dash Family’s Roles”

  • Mark Nichol

    Agua:
    Both approaches are widely used. I aesthetically prefer no spaces, which is common especially in print because when type is justified (aligned on straight left and right margins), typing a dash immediately adjacent to words does not effect how a line of type ends. But in ragged-right alignment, where each line ends naturally, one or more lines ending in a linkage such as “support—perhaps,” where the entire sequence knocks down to the next line because there isn’t enough room for it on the previous line, creating a deep “gouge” in the right margin, can be unsightly. That is one reason that, on websites with ragged-right margins, letter spaces are generally inserted before and after dashes.

  • Agua Caliente

    I just saw this:
    …GOP support — perhaps 10 in the…
    So, there should be spaces separating the dash from the nearest words?
    Not “…GOP support—perhaps 10 in the…”?

  • Agua Caliente

    GTK for the Mac, Michael. On Win7 (and likely higher), Alt + 0150 does the en. (You have to use the numeric keypad.) I’ve been using Alt + 0151 for the em; nice to have another tool.

  • Curtis Manges

    For my money this is all a bunch of folderol promoted by typographers to boost their sense of importance. You’ve listed four supposedly distinct characters, but only two of them are possible on a typewriter or as written by hand: one short and one long. Even at that, the long one is produced out of two of the short ones. Personally, I’d love having a proper em-dash available.

    Does anyone notice? Only typographers. If this were so important, why haven’t the they lobbied to have these symbols included in keyboards?

  • Michael Tevlin

    BTW, here’s how to insert an en dash (at least in Word 2011 for Mac): Option + Minus = en dash
    https://www.techwalla.com/articles/how-to-make-an-em-dash-on-a-mac

  • Petra

    Not many people (nor even the commonly used style manuals) seem to know or remember this, but the correct term for these is rule, not dash: en-rule and em-rule. The terms en-dash and em-dash are a sort of hybrid of technical and vernacular.

Leave a comment: