Draconian Implies Cruelty

By Maeve Maddox

During the recent Congressional gridlock regarding the federal budget, the word draconian has become a common epithet used to preface the words “budget cuts,” in the way the epithet “powerful” usually precedes “Ways and Means Committee.”

How appropriate is the use of draconian to describe budget cuts?

It depends.

Asking the Pentagon to cut some of its $463 billion non-war related expenditures is not the same as cutting off a thief’s hand for stealing. Eliminating programs that are keeping people alive, on the other hand, might appropriately be called draconian.

Apart from budget cuts, draconian is often used in contexts in which official procedures are seen as unnecessarily cruel or tyrannical:

Over the past week, the unrest in the Middle East deepened, with growing protests in Bahrain and Libya, and more draconian measures by the countries’ leaders to quash the opposition.

A new report this week from Human Rights Watch peers into China’s Draconian and ineffective incarceration of people struggling with drug addiction.

We are not going to take the draconian police measures necessary to deport 11 million people.

Draconian new measure requires police to arrest anybody who can’t prove they are a US citizen.

Since 2005, a rather draconian law has been adopted to deal with offenders. Failure to pay a ticket results in the revocation of driving privileges in Quebec.

Somali women complain of draconian Sharia restrictions.

Draconian [drā-kō’nē-ən ] is an eponym, a word derived from a person’s name:

draconian (or draconic) of, pertaining to, or characteristic of Draco, archon at Athens in 621 B.C., or the severe code of laws said to have been established by him; rigorous, harsh, severe, cruel. –OED

Although draconian has come to mean “unreasonably harsh,” Draco’s written code in which punishments were spelled out was seen at the time as being more just than arbitrary punishments inflicted by the local authority figure.
According to legend, Draco’s code prescribed death for most offenses. Plutarch passed along this much-quoted anecdote:

It is said that Drakon himself, when asked why he had fixed the punishment of death for most offenses, answered that he considered these lesser crimes to deserve it, and he had no greater punishment for more important ones.

I say “according to legend” because I’ve read that in the only fragment of Draco’s code that survives, exile (not death) is the punishment for homicide.

Draco’s name could have something to do with the fact that his code of laws entered Greek memory as being really really cruel: Greek dracon means “dragon” or “serpent.”

Bottom line: draconian is a strong word that conveys disregard for the humane treatment of others. It’s wasted as a mere synonym for extreme.

Click here to get access to 800+ interactive grammar exercises!


Share


4 Responses to “Draconian Implies Cruelty”

  • Lawrence S. Miller

    Hmm, I wonder is this not a good use of draconian?

    “Incidentally, it was France and the American Henry Morgenthau, Sr., which led the fight to make the consequences of that war as draconian, ruinous, and hateful as possible.”

    I think it is a good use of draconian, given the penalties inflicted on the Germans for having started WWI caused them inhuman suffering and were to become a primary cause of WWII.

    What say you?

  • ‘nora

    I don’t know; considering the nature of some of the budget cuts, ‘cruel’ might be an appropriate adjective.

  • Ken K

    Describing Sharia, the most fiendish of laws, as draconian is perhaps not draconian enough. Sharia rules are atrocities designed by a cruel god and implemented by executioners on a massive scale. I transgressed for being off the topic; forgive me.

  • Robert Browning

    Good to see you in print, Maeva.
    Hoping also to see a Solon or two arise before the next election 😉
    RB

Leave a comment: