It’s Not “The Ox-Bow Incidence”

background image 419

Have you ever heard someone say:

I’ve experienced a couple of incidences like that now.

The word wanted there is incidents, not incidences.

Incidence is one of those words, like disinterested and percentile, that tends to crop up where it doesn’t belong.

Both incident and incidence derive from a medieval Latin word with the sense of to fall into, to fall upon, or happen to. Look up both words in the OED and you will find numerous meanings.

All that need concern us here is the most common use of each word in modern English.

The title of the movie, by the way, is The Ox-Bow Incident.

As a noun incident means an occurrence or an event. It can be something trivial.

That reminds me of an incident that occurred while I was walking the dog.

Foreign travelers are warned against behavior that might provoke an “incident.” Here the meaning is an event that could lead to political difficulties between two governments.

Incidence has a mathematical meaning. In geometry it means

The situation of one locus with respect to another when they have a common point or points, but do not completely coincide; e.g. of a point to a line on which it lies, of a point or a line to a plane in which it lies, or of two intersecting lines to each other.

It’s a term used by airplane pilots:

The pilot is able to increase or decrease the lift by altering the angle of incidence. Ibid., As the angle of incidence increases, the lift also increases and the aircraft is able to climb, but if the tilt is made too large the flow on the upper surface separates and eddies are formed.

The most usual non-specialized meaning is

Manner of falling upon or affecting in any way; the range or scope of a thing, the extent of its influence or effects.

We can speak of the incidence of poverty in depressed areas of the country, or the incidence of disease in a given population.

Best advice: Don’t say incidence if all you mean is event, happening, or occurrence. That’s an incident.

Stop making those embarrassing mistakes! Subscribe to Daily Writing Tips today!

You will improve your English in only 5 minutes per day, guaranteed!

Each newsletter contains a writing tip, word of the day, and exercise!

You'll also get three bonus ebooks completely free!

5 thoughts on “It’s Not “The Ox-Bow Incidence””

  1. I was interested to see that ox-bow has a hyphen, but ox bow front or ox bow chest, as in furniture (also called yoke front), has a space.

    The oxbow, the u-shaped piece of wood (often steam-bent hardwood) that goes around the neck of the ox and up into the bar of the yoke is a single word. An oxbow lake, formed in the curve of an abandoned river channel, is also a single word. Oxcart is a single word, and oxblood, or oxblood red, (the dull, deep red color) is also a single word.

    An ox is a steer of any breed of cattle, trained to drive or for meat. In the US, common usage also means four years or more of age. Ox can also refer to any cattle. Plural for ox is oxen for one (1) or two (2), oxes for three (3).

    At least, according to my 1967 Random House Dictionary of the English Language.

  2. “Have you ever heard someone say:

    I’ve experienced a couple of incidences like that now.”

    – no, I haven’t. But I have heard people talk about a ‘couple of instances’, which I believe is acceptable.

  3. Brad,
    My preference is oxbow, but when writing about films, one must use their titles as they exist — even such horrors as Honey, I Shrunk the Kids (1989) and The Pursuit of Happyness (2006).

    PS I just discovered that there is a 2005 documentary that uses the same deliberate misspelling: Pursuit of Happyness directed by Patrick McGuinn. sigh.

  4. Ray,
    “I’ve experienced a couple of instances” would not be idiomatic, but “I remember a couple of instances in which I did such and such” would be.

  5. When I’m alone in the car and I hear “incidences” on the car radio, I shriek “you mean incidents!” Glad to know others realize the difference, because radio personalities apparently don’t.

Leave a Comment