Twitter
Email
RSSThe Past of “Pay” is “Paid”
A reader expresses dismay at lapses in the spelling of the past form of the verb pay:
An article in the Burlington (VT) Free Press today had this heading: Isle La Motte to vote on spending repayed funds.
[W]hen did repayed become an acceptable word?
The answer, of course, is that it hasn’t.
Note: a Free Press reader pointed out the misspelling on the paper’s site:
“repayed” ?? Who buyed your English classes?
and the misspelled word was promptly corrected.
Our DWT reader offers another, more unfortunate example:
My friend’s son received a report card from his teacher that read: Tate payed attention in class.
Language changes and irregular verbs morph into regular verbs with -ed endings, but some words are in such frequent use that the older forms endure. It’s difficult to understand how someone educated as a teacher or a journalist could fail to master such a basic irregular spelling as paid.
The OED does include the spelling “payed” as a form used “chiefly in the nautical sense”:
pay: v. To smear or cover (a wooden surface or join, esp. the seams of a ship) with pitch, tar, or other substance, so as to make watertight or resistant to damage. Also (occas.) with over.
Merriam-Webster lists “payed” as a past form used for another nautical expression:
pay: to slacken (as a rope) and allow to run out
For the everyday sense of pay as remuneration, the past tense is paid.
Two other common verbs ending in -ay that also change the y to i in the past are say and lay:
say/said/have said
lay/laid/have laid
Got Your Free eBook?
- Subscribe to Daily Writing Tips and you will be able to download our free ebook: Basic English Grammar.
- You will also get all our grammar, spelling, punctuation and writing tips.
- The download link will go along with the first email (you might need to wait up to 24 hours).
Subscribe
9 Responses to “The Past of “Pay” is “Paid””
Got something to say?
Sponsors
Recent Articles
- Using “May” in a Question
- Albatross and Alcatraz Island
- The Discount Is Back: Buy Our Book Today for $9.99
- Participles and Perfect Verb Tenses
- Writing Clinic #3: The Trip
- Do You Write Like Stephen King?
- Repudiate, Refute, and Reject
- Ingenious vs. Ingenuous
- “Sleazy” and “slazy”
- “Fun, Funner, Funnest”?
- Overwhelm and Underwhelm
- Spasmodic
- Learn the Forms of “drink,” Please!
- Bunting and Bunting
- Hyper and Hypo
I have been reading, writing and speaking for years of course. I am often suprised by the misuse of many words in their everyday use. But more than anything, I am shocked at how often professionals misuse and misspell words in their articles. The incorrect usage of paid, run and ran, lay and laid, there and their and so on is somewhat mind-boggling.
I am happy to see that I am not the only one who has noticed it.
Nice post.
Mike
Interestingly, by the by, here in Bristol (England) ‘laid’ is pronounced ‘led’ (like Standard ’sed’), while’ said’ is often pronounced ’sayed’!
Tony,
That is interesting. Here it’s the opposite. However, I have heard a few speakers on the radio make “said” rhyme with “laid.”
…And I thinked I amed bad at conjugation
But I also find it interesting how young children often start off using the past tenses accurately (e.g. I ran), then move to “I runned” – as they start to apply the rules of language as they’re learning them. Then realise they’ve got it wrong.
Perhaps some people never got to that last stage! (Or, for international speakers, have so many irregular verbs to learn that one or two inevitably get missed)
It seems obvious to me that the ‘mistake’ of repayed for repaid was due to having the “re” prefix. I’m sure the writer would have correctly written paid instead of payed.
What really amazes me is that the spell checker was turned off, assuming of course the writer was using computer.
Having said all that, in my view people strict when it comes to spelling, Payed is more logical then paid and it would be much easier for children to learn. We should seek to regularise verbs where they are irregular. Change is inevitable so get a life and embrace variety.
Thank you so much for this valuable information.
Very useful indeed.
Mr. Anderson, I am often “suprised” by the rate at which people will criticize others for their mistakes while unable to see their own.
Ha! And you are correct sir in pointing out my own mistake!!
Thank you,
Mike